Generalised Anxiety And Worry

Generalised anxiety problems involve excessive worry about several lifestyle domains such as health, finances, relationships, and so on. Such worrying usually takes up most of the individual's time and becomes highly disabling, both for the individuals concerned and for their partners, friends, and families. This so-called pathological worry is associated with a number of physiological somatic symptoms of fear or anxiety, although, for diagnostic purposes, it is not usually regarded as...

Miscellaneous disgustrelated disorders

The focus of this book is primarily on normal emotions and their associated disorders. However, there are a number of appetitive and drive-related disorders that may be based, in part, on a particular drive becoming the focus of a disgust-based reaction either as a primary part of the disorder or as a secondary feature in which some other motive is primary. Two groups of disorders to which this approach may usefully be applied are the eating disorders and the sexual disorders. The role of...

A formulation of the basic emotion debate in terms of the philosophy of emotion

In Chapter 2 we argued that the concept of emotion includes an event, a perception or interpretation, an appraisal, physiological change, a propensity for action, and conscious awareness. We further suggested that emotion as a paradigm case could also embrace overt behaviour. Within this conceptualisation we suggested that, in philosophical terms, it is only meaningful to distinguish one emotion from another on the basis of the appraisal component. That is to say, an emotion is specified as,...

Note On Complex Emotions

For ease of explication, we have restricted the examples we have used in this chapter to basic emotions such as fear or anger. It is therefore useful to clarify the ways in which so-called complex emotions can be derived from the basic five (see also Chapter 3). We propose three routes to the generation of complex emotions within SPAARS 1 A coupling of two basic emotions for example, sadness and happiness can become coupled to generate the emotion of nostalgia. 2 Further appraisal cycles which...

A reanalysis of Clarks theory of panic disorder within the Spaars framework

David Clark's theoretical work on panic has been extremely influential, especially within the clinical domain, and any analysis of panic phenomena within SPAARS would have much in common with Clark's ideas. Enshrined within the SPAARS approach is the proposal (see Chapters 2 and 5) that emotions consist of an event, an interpretation, an appraisal, physiological arousal, an action potential, conscious awareness (and behaviour). We can see that these components are clearly delineated within...

Anger with inappropriate attributions of agency

Paul is a 13-year-old boy with severe kidney problems which are being treated with regular and prolonged dialysis requiring frequent hospitalisation. Paul gets on reasonably well with his parents and friends but has a very bad relationship with his slightly older sister, Julie. Whenever Julie is around, Paul is always bullying her and shouting at her and sometimes her very presence seems to rouse him to uncontrollable rages. Paul is clearly and understandably angry at the world or fate for...

Appraisalbased generation of anger within SPAARS

Within SPAARS the core appraisal parameters that make the emotion one of anger reflect the research reviewed in the first part of the chapter and consist of the interruption or thwarting of an active goal, combined with an appraisal of agency. Within the SPAARS framework, the satisfaction of these two parameters is both necessary and sufficient for the generation of anger. However, as we have discussed in Chapter 5, the core appraisal parameters involved in a given basic emotion become refined...

Appraisals involved in the emotion of fear

In the emotion of fear, we propose that the first analysis by the appraisal system within SPAARS, as for all negative emotions (see Chapter 5), is that the event interpretation is appraised as incompatible in some way with existing goals and or models of the self, world, and other. The second cycle of the appraisal system, and the first specific to the emotion of fear, is the appraisal of threat that is, the appraisal that there is a chance of future non-completion of valued goals. Further...

Author index

Abelson, R.P. 138, 143, 144-145 Abrahamsen, A. 98 Abramson, L.Y. 87, 103, 104-107, 110, 120, 238, 244, 245, 252, 254 Ackerman, B.P. 165 Agras, W.S. 174 Ahrens, A.H. 252 Ainsworth, M.D.S. 230 Akhtar, S. 296, 309 Algom, D. 197 Allan, S. 313 Allen, N.B. 176 Alloy, L.B. 105, 110, 238, 245, 252, 254 Aquinas, T. 19, 38, 39-40, 41, 42, 86, 261 Argyle, M. 322, 325, 330, 332 Aristotle 6, 10, 19, 33-38, 39, 41, 42, 43, 49, 53, 58, 62, 73, 131, 260, 261, 268-269, 270, 330, 331, 334 Armfield, J.M. 200...

Avoidance phenomena

The magnitude of the intrusive phenomena leads individuals to recruit a number of protective mechanisms and processes. They are likely consciously to endeavour to avoid any reminders of the trauma and will try not to think about the trauma or talk about it. In addition, individuals may minimise their interaction with the world generally by withdrawing socially in order to reduce the number of putative triggering stimuli. Other extreme avoidance symptoms of PTSD such as psychogenic amnesia are...

Biases of memory

One of the most heavily researched areas of bias in the emotional disorders has been the area of mnemonic biases in depression. For example, an influential study by Lloyd and Lishman (1975) reported that depressed patients were faster to recall unpleasant than pleasant memories in response to neutral cue words. In a cleverly designed application of this procedure, Clark and Teasdale (1982) tested a group of depressed patients who showed considerable diurnal variation in their mood, and found...

Cognitive theories of emotion

APPROACHES TO EMOTION NETWORK THEORIES APPRAISAL THEORIES SUMMARY My soul is a hidden orchestra I know not what instruments, what fiddlestrings and harps, drums and tambours I sound and clash inside myself. All I hear is the symphony. The purpose of this chapter is to outline some of the major current cognitive theories of emotion in psychology. Our focus will therefore be more on the adequacy of these theories as theories (Dalgleish, 2004) than on the empirical data, which will be considered...

Concluding Remarks

In this final chapter on the basic emotions, we have made two important shifts in the focus of our theoretical analysis. The first is from the consideration of negative emotions to the consideration of positive ones the second is from an analysis of emotions related to the fate of specific goals to the consideration of an emotional state, which for the present purposes we have labelled Happiness, which reflects the goal status of the whole system. However, we do wish to emphasise, along with...

Depression parasuicide and suicide

The putative relationship between depression and disgust has been dealt with in detail in Chapter 7. We argued for an analysis of depression in which the basic emotions of sadness and disgust may become coupled and thereby maintain the individual in a painful emotional state which may prove difficult to alter or regulate. Instead of covering the same ground again therefore, we will focus on the related problems of suicide and parasuicide. However, we will make a brief comment on the increasing...

Emotion generation

Having finished our rather lengthy introduction by indicating how the various domains of knowledge, including goals, are accommodated within the representational structure we have outlined, we can now return at last to a discussion of the emotions. In this section we will outline the first of two ways in which the various components of the emotion process might operate within the framework that we have sketched so far. The most instructive way to demonstrate the generation of emotions via the...

Further Comments And Conclusions

In relation to the more general SPAARS theory presented earlier in this chapter and in Chapter 5, we suggest that in depression-prone individuals there is a preoccupation with an overinvested role or goal. A major threat to or loss of this dominant role or goal leads the individual to focus on the aspects of the self-concept that are normally rejected and the lost role or goal that was central to self-worth (Champion & Power, 1995). This preoccupation with the lost role or goal leads to...

Gap accounts of happiness

The research we have considered above on the affective and resource correlates of self-reported happiness has taken the participant's avowed happiness as a starting point and systematically investigated aspects of the individual's life which might be related to feeling happy. In contrast, gap theories are concerned with the processes that might underly self-reports of happiness that is, what determines whether individuals will report that they are happy. Such gap theories of happiness (e.g.,...

General comments on bias research

The findings from studies of cognitive biases in depressed and normal moods show that there are a number of effects. Perhaps the strongest evidence for bias in depression comes from work on explicit memory including word-list and autobiographical memory tasks. However, these studies emphasise that the clearest biases are obtained in the processing of self-related negative material rather than any negative material. The fact that findings for biases in implicit memory tasks have been less...

Happiness Order And Happiness Disorder

The concept of happiness disorder is one that is rarely discussed in the emotion literature. Perhaps it is because, in Western society, we are more tolerant of variations and extremes within the parameters, both cognitive and physiological, that define a particular individual's positive emotions, and are thus less likely to label the emotion as disordered in comparison to the case of extreme variants of negative emotions such as anger, fear, or sadness. In other non-Western cultures happiness...

Hyperarousal

The process of dealing with the existence of unintegrated traumatic information in memory can lead to the various manifestations of hyperarousal in different ways. First, as we have suggested above, the fear module within SPAARS is continuously being activated and reactivated by both the direct appraisal of the unintegrated representations of trauma-related information within memory and also via multiple cueing from the environment second, such continual appraisals utilise executive processing...

Indignation hatred and wrath

Solomon (1993) in his book The Passions has argued that indignation differs from anger in that its criteria are more authoritative that is, they are more strongly moral than in the case of anger, and consequently the individual experiencing indignation is more self-righteous. Solomon proposes that these fundamental differences lead to others (the person or institution towards whom anger is directed) being viewed as inferior and that this further increases the indignant individual's own sense of...

Inhibition and facilitation

In a number of chapters we have highlighted the roles that inhibition and facilitation play in the expression of emotion (see also Dalgleish et al., 1999). It was pointed out, for example, that many cultures have preferences for which of the basic emotions are permissible and which are not thus, the Ifaluk treat happiness as a negative emotion because it makes the sufferer blind to the needs of others and full of pride for the self (Lutz, 1988). As the bible also reminds us Pride goeth before...

Involved In Anger

Research shows that there is considerable agreement within a given society on what exactly the events, agents, interpretations, and appraisals that appropriately lead to anger might be (Averill, 1982 Ben-Zur & Breznitz, 1991 Russell & Fehr, 1994 Scherer & Wallbott, 1994). This agreement is far from being a trivial point, which is clear from an analysis of the homicide law in the United States (Averill, 1982 Oatley, 1992). To summarise, in the US legal system it is possible for a...

Jealousy and envy

O, beware, my lord, of jealousy It is the green-ey'd monster which doth mock the meat it feeds on. Shakespeare's green ey'd monster of jealousy is a highly complex beast and has no better presentation in literature than in Othello. Neu (1980) points out, That jealousy has such rich surroundings, that we make such a wealth of fine discriminations in the area of jealousy (envy, resentement, indignation, schadenfreude, begrudging, malice, spite, ill will, hatred, ingratitude, revenge, hostility,...

Joy And Other Circumscribed Positive Emotions

Joy may be conceptualised as the emotional state related to an appraisal that a valued goal has been achieved, or that movement towards such an achievement has occurred. So, for example, somebody might feel joy when she is able to go and book her summer holiday. Such an analysis of joy clearly distinguishes it from what we shall call happiness. Joy is very much an emotional reaction to a specific goal in a specific domain, whereas happiness, it seems, casts its appraisal net much wider. It is...

Langs network theory

In Lang's (1979, 1984 Bradley & Lang, 2000) network approach, propositions are represented in the network through a combination of labelled nodes and links. Following Kintsch's (1974) suggestion that sentences can be represented as combinations of one or more propositions that take the form PREDICATE(ARGUMENT1, ARGUMENT2, . . .), nodes in a network are taken to represent arguments that are connected by links that are labelled with predicates thus, in the example shown in Figure 3.10, the...

Learned helplessness

The original learned helplessness theory was presented in detail in Seligman's classic book published in 1975. Although the theory has subsequently undergone revisions, the role of perceived non-contingency continues to play an important role. The original proposal began with Seligman's laboratory work with dogs. In the studies, the dogs were placed in a shuttle-box, which was designed so that on some occasions the dog could jump from one side of the box to the other, but on other occasions a...

Mind content revisited

We propose that the three domains of knowledge are represented across the various representational formats in similar ways. If we consider knowledge of the world as an example, we propose that abstract models of the world, such as the world as a safe place, would be represented at the schematic model level WORLD - SAFE PLACE . However, less abstracted information about the world, such as the fact that the chances of being mugged alone in Central Park at night are high, would be represented at...

Network Theories

Network theories follow in a long tradition that can be traced back to Aristotle and which includes the British empiricist or associationist school of philosophy. In psychology, associationism underpins not only behaviourism and the basis for the laws of learning, but also psychoanalysis and Freud's development of the free association technique. Indeed, one of the most detailed and elegant network models of autobiographical memory was presented by Breuer and Freud (1895). Because it bears close...

Nonnormative events agents interpretations and appraisals implicated in anger

When the schematic models of self, world, and others differ from those that can be inferred from the diary studies discussed earlier that is, when they are non-normative then the generation and expression of anger in those individuals can appear abnormal. Averill calls this anger gone awry to quote Inappropriate behaviour, especially of a violent nature, may also result from a failure of an individual to internalise appropriate regulative rules. Of course, what is considered appropriate in this...

Oatley and Johnson Laird

The next appraisal theory that we will consider is that of Oatley and Johnson-Laird (1987 see also Oatley, 1992, and Johnson-Laird & Oatley, 2000). Oatley and Johnson-Laird propose that in a system engaged in multiple goals and plans there have to be mechanisms by which priority can be assigned, because not all active goals and plans can be pursued at once. They argue that one of the important roles for emotion, therefore, is to provide a possible mechanism by which such priorities can be...

Other Affective Disorders

Other rarer affective disorders include the bipolar disorders and the seasonal affective disorders. Because of the important role of mania and hypomania in the diagnosis of bipolar disorders, we will hold the discussion of these until Chapter 10 when we discuss disorders of the basic emotion of happiness. The key paper on seasonal affective disorder (SAD) was by Rosenthal et al. (1984). Rosenthal and his colleagues described a seasonal pattern for a sample of 29 individuals in which there was a...

Panic

Mary was a 23-year-old woman with a family history of schizophrenia. At the age of 18, Mary suffered a bad viral complaint and one evening when she was feeling particularly under the weather, she started to become very anxious about her blocked throat, her headache, and her fuzzy thinking. The anxiety seemed to build and build until Mary went into a state where she felt unable to breathe and thought she was going to faint. When asked about it afterwards, Mary reported that she had been...

Physiological components of the fear response

We all know what it is like to feel afraid we may sweat more, feel flushed, experience changes in our breathing, increases in heart rate, intestinal discomfort, muscular tension, dry mouth, butterflies in the stomach, and so on. There has been an enormous amount of research and theoretical discussion on the physiological subsystems that subsume these experiences of fear (e.g., Barlow, 2002). The important point that we would like to emphasise here about the physiological components of fear is...

Preface to second edition

In the 10 years since we published the first edition of this book, the area of emotion in general and affective neuroscience in particular has expanded rapidly and deservedly. However, there is always a risk that an area does move on, and that one's treasured views and theories have to be abandoned or substantially altered because of progress in relevant fields. It was with some trepidation, therefore, that we approached the writing of this second edition Would the basic emotions approach...

Preliminary remarks

The term melancholia was first used in the fifth century bc by Hippocrates. Based on the ancient doctrine of the four elements, four humours were identified in blood, each of which in excess could lead to problems thus, the melancholic type suffered an excess of black bile. Whichever type you were though, the treatment was usually the same bloodletting. Over the subsequent thousand years and more a lot of melancholic individuals lost an awful lot of blood. Galen in the first century ad added...

Problems and subsequent revisions

Although Bower's theory met with much success, it became apparent that there were a number of empirical and theoretical problems. The theory makes the broad prediction that each mood state should be associated with a range of perceptual, attentional, and mnemonic biases. However, it became clear that different types of biases tend to be Figure 3.8 The effect of mood induction on the retrieval of pleasant and unpleasant childhood memories (based on Bower, 1981). associated with different mood...

Rationality irrationality and the function of emotions

When given a choice, people are less likely to choose an operation if told they have a 7 chance of dying than if they are told that they have a 93 chance of survival (e.g., Sutherland, 1994). These and a whole range of similar observations have come to question the long-cherished belief of the rationality of the Western male at best it would seem that we can approximate to logic or rationality in our thinking, but there are a host of circumstances under which logic and rationality disappear in...

Recall recognition and implicit memory tasks

Mathews, Mogg, May, and Eysenck (1988) investigated explicit and implicit memory in groups of people with GAD, recovered anxious participants, and controls. The explicit memory task was a free recall paradigm and, in line with previous findings with GAD patients (e.g., Mogg, Mathews, & Weinman, 1987), there were no significant effects. The implicit memory paradigm was a word completion task. The participants were simply instructed to complete a word stem with the first word that came to...

Reformulated learned helplessness

The original 1975 theory was later reformulated by Abramson et al. (1978) an essentially equivalent reformulation was offered independently by Miller and Norman (1979), but, not surprisingly, credit for the reformulation has remained with the theory's originator. The important features of the reformulation are presented in Figure 4.1. In short, Abramson et al. added Weiner's attribution theory (see Chapter 3) to the original learned helplessness approach that is, although helplessness continued...

Ren Descartes

Descartes presents his theory of emotion in his pamphlet On the Passions of the Soul, where he starts with the most wonderful dismissal of all previous philosophical discourse on the subject (academic life would be so much easier if one could also start with the same dismissal of everything that has gone before) . . . what the ancients taught about them the passions is so little, and for the most part so little believable, that I cannot hope to approach the truth unless I forsake the paths they...

Roles goals and plans

One of the important features of the SPAARS approach, with important therapeutic implications, is the centrality of the individual's roles and goals and the ways in which events are appraised in relation to these goals and plans. For example, the extent to which an individual will experience happiness, anger, depression, or whatever will, to a considerable degree, depend on the nature of that person's roles and goals, the extent to which roles and goals are achievable and realistic, the extent...

Some Theoretical Comments

Darwin's (1872) views on the role of emotion were considered briefly in Chapter 3. We noted that although Darwin considered many aspects of emotion to be evolutionarily vestigial, he drew attention to the importance of the facial expression of emotions and how these were apparent in different cultures. He noted too that cultural variation also occurred in the case of disgust, he recorded numerous instances in his diaries of The Voyage of The Beagle (1839 1988) of cultural practices that evoked...

Some Theoretical Remarks Concerning A Theory Of Mind

As we have seen above, in our review of psychological theories of emotional order and disorder in Chapters 3 and 4 we introduced a number of important topics from cognitive psychology, such as modularity, multiple representations, and so forth. These ideas were presented very much on a need to know basis, addressing only those details necessary to understand the theory under discussion. This has left us Table 5.2 Principal points derived from Chapters 2-4, which any comprehensive model of...

T I

Figure 3.11 An emotion prototype (based on Lang, 1983). example, in the case of phobic anxiety Lang argued that three types of propositional networks were closely coordinated to form an emotion prototype or emotion schema (see Figure 3.11). These three networks consist of a stimulus network, a meaning network, and a response network. The stimulus network is directly linked in to the perceptual input and produces a representation of the input irrespective of its modality. In the case of certain...

The Aristotelian functionalist model of emotion

Aristotle presents his functionalist doctrine of the mind principally in the De Anima (1941). The first important distinction he emphasises is between matter and form. There are two fundamental questions that we can ask about any individual entity first, what is it made of what is its matter And, second, what is it that makes it what it is rather than something else what is its form So, if we take the example of a hamburger, its matter is bits of salad, meat, and bread. However, if these were...

The behaviourist theory of James Watson

Watson's view of emotions sets out its stall in order to repudiate the sort of feeling theory offered by William James. One would therefore imagine, given the meteoric rise of behaviourism, that James' theory would never have been heard of again. However, as we noted above, James' ideas continue to be influential to the present day. The reason for this becomes clear if we put aside James' discussion of feelings as the sensation of bodily change (because within Watson's Behaviorism we are unable...

The generation of emotion via the associative level of representation some preliminary remarks

In Chapter 3 we reviewed associative network theories of emotion. We began with a discussion of Bower's theory (e.g., Bower, 1981 Bower & Forgas, 2000) in which emotions are represented by single nodes in a localised network. Having suggested numerous empirical and theoretical problems with this type of model (see Chapter 3 for a fuller discussion) we speculated on the advantages of a distributed network or parallel distributed processing architecture for the modelling of emotions (although...

The interaction of inhibition and emotion emotion modules and the inhibition of emotional experience

We have proposed in the preceding two sections that the configuration of the SPAARS system is a function of the dominant schematic models and is maintained by a combination of facilitation and inhibition throughout the system. What is the interaction between these processes and emotion We have stressed throughout the book so far that emotions have functionality, and we have proposed a cognitive theory of emotions in the present chapter that employs the concept of roles and goals to provide a...

The Picture So

In Chapter 2 we reviewed the development of philosophical ideas about emotions. We finished the chapter by setting out a number of philosophical ground rules to which, we suggested, any theory of emotion must adhere if it is to make philosophical sense. These ground rules provide us with some of the main components of emotional experiences within a broadly functional theory of mind. What the rules do not do is to say very much about the psychological processes underlying emotional experience...

The reformulated frustrationaggression hypothesis

In 1939 an eminent group of psychologists, sociologists, and anthropologists published a small book in which they set out a theoretical framework for understanding frustration and aggression (Dollard, Doob, Miller, Mowrer, & Sears, 1939). Their basic thesis was as follows (1) The occurrence of aggression presupposes the existence of frustration and (2) the existence of frustration always leads to some form of aggression. Dollard et al. defined frustation as an interference with the...

The relationship between goal structures and schematic models within SPAARS

In Chapter 5 we developed the idea that, at the schematic model level of representation within SPAARS, individuals possess a variety of models of the world, self, and others which form the basis of their reality. For most of us there is a sense that the world is a reasonably safe place, that we have more or less control over what goes on in our world, that the actions of other people are pretty much predictable, that bad things don't usually happen to us, and so on (Dalgleish, 2004a). These...

The Spaars model of anger

We have outlined the SPAARS model of emotion in detail in Chapter 5, and in the present chapter we endeavour to use the case of anger primarily to illustrate the potential utility of the concept of cycles of appraisal within SPAARS. In passing, however, we would note that part of the general SPAARS model, which is the assumption that anger is one of a limited set of basic emotions, has received some preliminary neuropsychological support from a study of four cases of individuals with impairment...

The Thomistic account of emotions

A number of commentators (e.g., Lyons, 1980, 1992) have argued that the Thomistic account of emotions is essentially a non-cognitive one. In fact, Aquinas himself proposes that passions, and therefore emotions, are seated in what he terms the orectic rather than in the cognitive part of the soul (Summa Theologica 1a, 2ae, Q. 22, Art. 2). In contrast we would like to suggest that the Thomistic model has cognitive elements without being a fully fledged cognitive theory in the Aristotelian vein....

Their relationship with each other

It seems unlikely that it is possible to answer the question of how many emotions there are, or even whether it is meaningful to ask it. Some of the early philosophical analyses of emotion such as those of Aristotle and Descartes did present lists of emotions, but even here it is unclear whether they viewed these lists as illustrative or finite. Within cognitive theory the sensible approach would be that the number of emotions is determined by the number of states that fit the conceptual...

To emotions

In Chapter 2 on the cognitive philosophy of emotion we stressed that an important component of emotions is appraisal and that it is only by virtue of this component that one emotion can reliably be distinguished from another. Any appraisal that an individual makes has to be with respect to something. So, if we take a simple example, we have suggested that the emotion of fear is characterised by appraisals of unwanted psychological or physical threat. This begs the question of what we mean when...

Too Much Anger Versus Too Little

We headed this chapter with a quotation from Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics in which he suggests that the trick with anger is not to be angry but to be angry in the right way that is, anger should be an appropriate response to events in their social and psychological context. As with much of the discussion in this chapter, this proposal applies not just to anger but to all emotions. Consider Aristotle again For instance, both fear and confidence and appetite and anger and pity and in general...

Towards a core set of basic emotions

In this discussion of basic emotions we have tried to argue that the most profitable approach to the question of basicness is in terms of a core set of basic appraisal scenarios that emerge in most, if not all, human societies, and the emotions that incorporate these appraisal scenarios are the basic emotions. However, analysis of appraisal parameters is still very much a theoretical exercise, so it remains fruitful to examine the conclusions from other lines of investigation of basic emotions,...

Twentiethcentury Cognitive Accounts Of Emotion

The resurgence of cognitivism was largely a reaction against the stifling effects of behaviourism with its dismissal of all internal psychological states, just as behaviourism itself was a reaction against feeling theory with its overemphasis on private experience. The development of this new cognitivism went hand in hand with advances in computer technology such that, in psychology, the metaphor of the mind as a computer became dominant (e.g., Miller, Galanter, & Pribram, 1960). In the...

Two routes to emotion

One of the distinctive characteristics of the SPAARS model is the fact that emotion can occur through either of two possible routes (see Figure 11.1 above see also Power & Dalgleish, 1999). The first route is one that is shared with other appraisal theories of emotion and has been sketched in the previous section. The second route, however, requires further comment, both in terms of its operation and in terms of its relationship to the interpretive-appraisal route. The need for two routes to...

What distinguishes an emotion from a nonemotion

As we noted at the beginning of the chapter, there is a considerable folk-psychological consensus about which mental states are the emotions, e.g., fear, anger, guilt, and so on. Likewise, there is general agreement that hunger, pain, itches, etc. are not emotions. The challenge for any model of emotion, we suggested, is to produce a conceptual framework from which these accepted distinctions between emotions and non-emotions emerge. The most difficult of these distinctions is that between...

George Mandler

Mandler (e.g., 1984) has developed a theory over a number of years that bears many similarities to Schachter and Singer's proposals while presenting a more complex role for cognitive processes. In Mandler's theory, physiological arousal is considered to arise from perceived discrepancy or from the interruption to an ongoing goal or plan. The arousal is seen as an undifferentiated physiological state that underlies both positive and negative emotions cognition determines which emotion is...

Sadness Some Theoretical Considerations

Following the outline general model presented in Chapter 5 of the SPAARS approach to emotion, we will now consider the application of the model to sadness. The focus will initially be on all forms of sadness, but in subsequent sections we will examine how the model applies to the extreme forms of sadness seen in grief, and to the sadness-based disorder of depression. Three of the key points that we proposed in Chapter 5 were that basic emotions have the potential to develop in a modular...

The analogicalpropositional debate

The debate between proponents of analogical and propositional mental representations is one of the oldest in cognitive psychology. Theoreticians such as Paivio (see Paivio, 1971, 1986) have argued that both forms of representation are essential to any understanding of human cognition. In contrast, psychologists such as Pylyshyn (e.g., 1973, 1984) have proposed that all mental knowledge can be represented in propositional terms. What then do we mean by the terms analogical and propositional The...

Bowers network theory

The most influential network theory of emotion was proposed by Gordon Bower (Bower, 1981, 1992 Bower & Cohen, 1982 Bower & Forgas, 2000). Based on the earlier Anderson and Bower (1973) Human Associative Memory (HAM) model, Bower proposed that concepts, events, and emotions can all be represented as nodes within a network. In fact, the type of network originally chosen by Anderson and Bower consisted only of labelled links the nodes themselves had no semantic labels. However, for ease of...

Schachter and Singer

The basic proposal of the Schachter and Singer (1962) theory was that emotion involved the cognitive interpretation of a state of bodily arousal (see Figure 3.12). This state of arousal was considered to be a general one, in that the same arousal underpinned both positive and negative emotions the crucial determinant for the type of emotion experienced was how the individual explained the state of arousal. To quote from Schachter and Singer Precisely the same state of physiological arousal...

Disordered Fear And Anxiety

Fear and anxiety can become disordered in a variety of ways. We can experience excessive fear to relatively harmless objects or we can develop beliefs that certain things are threatening or harmful when they are not. In other situations fear or anxiety can seem appropriate but overgeneralised such as in post-traumatic reactions or chronic worry. The challenge for any theory that seeks to explain both fear order and fear disorder is to account for the varieties of abnormal fear without making...

The cognitive theory of Spinoza

The next significant emergence of the cognitive stream was provided by the Dutch-born philosopher Baruch Benedict Spinoza (1632-1677) in The Ethics (1677 1955). Scruton warns Spinoza's greatness and originality are hidden behind a remote, impassive, and often impenetrable style. Few have understood his arguments in their entirety. This seems to apply particularly to Spinoza's writing on emotions. He sets out in The Ethics to provide derivations from first principles of the essential properties...

Biases of reasoning and judgement

A number of earlier studies of judgement in depression showed that although depressed individuals were clearly more negative than their non-depressed counterparts (e.g., DeMonbreun & Craighead, 1977), nevertheless they were often found to be more realistic or accurate on such tasks (Lewinsohn, Mischel, Chaplin, & Barton, 1980). The classic statement of this position was by Alloy and Abramson (1979) who, from a series of judgement of contingency studies with depressed and normal students,...

Why do we have emotions

Although we introduced the idea of functionalism in our discussion of the work of Aristotle, we have given the question of why we have emotions little consideration. To recapitulate, the Aristotelian reply to the question, why do we have emotions is that the function of emotions is related to the propensity they allow for certain types of behaviour (cf. Dennett, 1991). So, the function of fear is to provide a propensity for Susan to run away from the bear. One might even add that the...

The Psychologising Of Feeling Theory William James

Despite the difficulties with feeling theory, it can rank among its proponents some of the greatest names in Western philosophy. John Locke's description of pain and pleasure and the emotions they give rise to is thoroughly Cartesian, though less fully articulated. He states that pain and pleasure cannot be described, nor their names defined the way of knowing them is, as of the simple ideas of the senses, only by experience (An Essay Concerning Human Understanding II, 20 see Kenny, 1963, for a...

Complex Emotions Derived From Disgust

The complex emotions of guilt, shame, and embarrassment are part of the group known as self-conscious emotions (e.g., Lewis, 1993) in that they require an internal evaluation of the self against a set of rules, standards, or goals and in which the self or some aspect of the self is seen to have failed (see Figure 9.2). There is now agreement that guilt refers in particular to specific aspects or acts which fall short of some standard, whereas in shame it is the self rather than some specific...

Obsessivecompulsive disorders

The obsessive-compulsive disorders (OCDs) have long been derived from anxiety in the main classification systems. This tradition follows in part the early analysis of OCD and other disorders by Freud who proposed, among many other things, that consciously experienced anxiety is a consequence of the transformation of repressed libido (e.g., Breuer & Freud, 1895). Thus, the most recent American (DSM-IV) and World Health Organization (ICD-10) classification systems both include obsessive-...

Socialcognitive theories of depression

The threads of various strands for current social-cognitive theories of depression can be seen first in the work on the vulnerability that arises for an individual who overinvests in one particular role (Becker, 1971) or goal (Arieti & Bemporad, 1978) and second in the work on life events and depression carried out by Brown and Harris (1978), in which a number of social vulnerability factors were highlighted because of their interaction with adversity to increase an individual's likelihood...

Sadness

CONSIDERATIONS 226 COMBINATIONS OF SADNESS AND OTHER FURTHER COMMENTS AND CONCLUSIONS 256 When sorrows come, they come not single spies, but in battalions. Sadness is little studied in psychology. This failure is surprising given its widespread portrayal in art, the cinema, music, and literature. Instead, the more extreme variants of sadness such as grief, bereavement, and mourning, or disorders derived from sadness such as depression have dominated psychological study (cf. Barr-Zisowitz,...

Individual differences at the schematic model level

It is important to elaborate on the types of models of self, world, and others which we propose that the individual holds at the schematic model level of meaning within SPAARS, and how they relate to the individual's prior emotional and developmental history, in order to try to understand the enormous range of individual differences in the way people respond to traumatic events. Dalgleish (2004) has proposed that there are five main types of pre-trauma personalities that interact with the...

Hopelessness theory

A number of the problems with the reformulated learned helplessness theory have led at least some of its proponents to offer a second reformulation which they have called hopelessness theory (Abramson et al., 1988, 1989). Both in terms of name and in terms of content, hopelessness theory has been placed squarely within the framework of Beck's cognitive therapy. Because we will deal with Beck's approach in the next section, the coverage of hopelessness theory will be brief and will focus on the...

Normal Fear And Anxiety

To review the conceptualisation of fear within the SPAARS framework it might be useful to consider a new example after all, Susan has been running from the bear for so long now that she is almost certainly exhausted. Let us consider a common example from the cognitive therapy literature (e.g., Beck et al., 1979). Imagine the event of a loud noise in your house (in which you are alone) in the middle of the night. There are a number of interpretations of such an event for example, one might...

Novacos cognitiveclinical approach to anger

Novaco's (e.g. 1975, 1979) model of anger is the most influential in the clinical context and has recently been adapted for working with anger problems in people with intellectual disabilities (Taylor & Novaco, 2005). A schematic flow diagram of Novaco's formulation is presented in Figure 8.3. In Novaco's model, external events are cognitively processed and may lead to a state of emotional arousal. This arousal is a general physiological response, which may be labelled differently by the...

The Cognitive Approach In Psychology

We have already touched on some characteristics of the cognitive approach to emotion in our initial remarks on Aristotle and his current functionalist influence on philosophy and psychology. However, before launching into detailed accounts of cognitive models of emotion and the emotional disorders, it is first necessary to provide some groundwork about the cognitive approach and what we see as its most useful characteristics. As with any approach, there are a number of distinct churches...

Fredricksons broadenandbuild theory of happiness

Barbara Fredrickson (1998, 2001) has proposed the so-called broaden-and-build theory of positive emotions. The broaden component of the theory refers to the current function of positive emotions whereas negative emotions are considered to restrict the available thought-action repertoires and increase the likelihood of specific action tendencies, positive emotions are considered to do the opposite. That is, positive emotions are considered to broaden the range of available thought-action...

Two routes revisited fast versus slow change processes in therapy

The evidence clearly shows that emotion responses can be learned and activated without benefit of neocortex and thought processes . . . This makes them difficult to access and treat through interventions that are strictly cognitive in nature. Emotions acquired through subcortical pathways are difficult to extinguish by any technique. (Izard, 1994, p. 151) In Izard's further advice to himself and other would-be therapists, he points to the danger of assuming that there is only one route to...

Summary Of The Aims Of This Book

In order to provide a guiding framework we will now offer a menu, with comments, of what is to be found in the remaining chapters in this book. This menu will, we hope, provide sufficient information for some selection of the dishes that individual readers might prefer to spend longer over, in addition to those that they might prefer to avoid or merely taste and pass quickly on to the next course. The book is divided into two main parts Part 1 is mainly theoretical and reviews a range of...

Cognitive theories of emotional disorder

SELIGMAN'S LEARNED HELPLESSNESS THEORY 103 In the vast colony of our being there are many different kinds of people, all thinking and feeling differently. The cognitive theories presented in Chapter 3 took normal emotions as their starting point. However, there are a number of influential cognitive approaches to emotion that have taken their starting points to be disorders of emotion rather than normal emotions themselves. These theories will form the focus of the present chapter. In contrast...

The ambiguous sentence task

Interpretation biases in anxiety were investigated by Eysenck, Mogg, May, Richards, and Mathews (1991). They presented people with GAD, recovered anxious people, and control participants with a series of sentences. Some of the sentences were ambiguous, with both threatening and non-threatening interpretations (e.g., The two men watched as the chest was opened.). After presentation of the sentences, the participants were given an unexpected recognition memory test, in which they had to decide...

Overview and conclusions

SUMMARY OF THE SPAARS MODEL META-EMOTIONAL SKILLS AND REPRESENTATIONS THERAPEUTIC IMPLICATIONS FINAL COMMENTS ON SPAARS You miss 100 of the shots you never take. As in ice-hockey, so in real life. We have taken shots at most things throughout the previous chapters in this book on the principle that if you don't shoot you'll never hit the target, but at the same time we are mindful that many of the shots will inevitably miss. The aims of this final chapter are therefore to draw together the key...

Becks Cognitive Therapy

Therapists (e.g., Clark, 1986 Teasdale, 1983, 1999) have argued for a circular relationship between cognition and emotion rather than a simple linear one we will examine Clark's approach to panic in more detail in the next section and in Chapter 6. There are two main components to the theory from which the general therapeutic approach is derived (see Figure 4.3). The first of these focuses on the types of cognitive structures that underlie the emotional disorders and the second focuses on the...

Summary

In this final section we would like to replay some of the edited highlights from the theories presented in this chapter. These points, along with those from Chapters 2 and 4, will then be carried forward to Chapter 5 where we will attempt an integration of current theories. Each theory that we have examined, like all theories, has both strengths and weaknesses. Even some of the earlier theories that many now consider to be incorrect were influential enough to spawn empirical research that...

Disbelief dissociation and modularisation

The first thing I would do if I were returning to teaching and practising psychotherapy is remind myself that the modularity of emotions is central to understanding and treating a number of human problems. The principle of modularity means that each emotion exists as a relatively independent and dissociable module with powers for organising and motivating specific sorts of cognition and action. (Izard, 1994, p. 149, author's own italics) Izard's advice to himself is completely in tune with the...

Towards A Theoretical Account Of Happiness

As we have stated above, for the purposes of the present chapter, whether or not an individual is happy conflates across many goals in different domains and at different levels of the system. In the domain of positive emotion, experiences such as joy or exhilaration are responses to the achievement of or movement towards active goals and are more akin to the states of anger, fear, sadness, and disgust. We are not presenting anything new here this understanding of happiness has been around for...

Hypomania and mania

Mrs Evans had been diagnosed by the junior psychiatrist as suffering from mania. She had been brought into the emergency referral clinic by her son who had come home to find her sitting in the living room surrounded by new, expensive commodities she had purchased with her cheque book, even though there was not enough money in the bank to cover the outgoings. Mrs Evans was extremely happy about her new acquisitions but, when her son pointed out that she had done something wrong, she very quickly...

The arguments for basic emotions

A host of different writers and researchers have pledged to the cause of basic emotions (e.g., Arnold, 1960 Ekman, Friesen, & Ellsworth, 1982 Gray, 1982 Izard, 1971 James, 1884 Mowrer, 1960 Oatley & Johnson-Laird, 1987 Panksepp, 1982 Plutchik, 1980 Watson, 1930 see Table 3.1. While acknowledging a diversity among proponents of the basic emotion concept, Ekman, Friesen, and Ellsworth (1972) have pointed out that every investigator has obtained evidence for a central list of six basic...

Werner

The attribution theory of emotion presented by Weiner (e.g., 1985, 1986) provides one of the transitional theories between the earlier undifferentiated arousal approaches and some of the more recent appraisal approaches that posit two or more differentiated states that are characteristic of emotions. For example, in relation to the Zajonc-initiated debate about the primacy of affect, Weiner sits on the fence It is entirely possible that in some instances feelings antedate causal thoughts. For...

Clarks adaptation of cognitive therapy for panic

So far the discussion of cognitive therapy has been dominated by reference to depression, but in order to illustrate how the approach can be modified and applied to other emotional disorders we will briefly mention David Clark's (1986) cognitive model of panic, which will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 6. The key theme in both Beck's general approach to anxiety (Beck & Emery, 1985) and in Clark's (1986) application of the approach to panic disorder is that the individual is...

Leventhal and Scherer

In 1987 Howard Leventhal and Klaus Scherer combined forces and produced a joint cognitive theory of emotion based on their previously separate ideas. Leventhal and Scherer argue that the operation of cognition and emotion is one of interdependence. They distinguish between emotion and other reflex-like responses, because although reflexes may play important roles as elements of emotional reactions Emotional processes decouple automatic, reflex responses from their eliciting stimuli and provide...

Combinations Of Sadness And Other Basic Emotions

One of the possibilities that we suggested in Chapter 5 was that two or more basic emotions could, under certain circumstances, continuously activate each other. This coupling between emotion modules can be considered to work in a similar way to the within-module activation that was outlined in the previous section. The proposal does of course run counter to a number of emotion theories such as that of Oatley and Johnson-Laird (1987), in which it was argued that complex emotions were derived...

Cognitive theoretical models of PTSD

A number of psychological paradigms provide frameworks for understanding PTSD, for example psychodynamic (e.g., Freud, 1919), learning theory (e.g., Keane, Zimmering, & Caddell, 1985), and cognitive (e.g., Horowitz, 1986). While all of these paradigms encompass theories that offer interesting insights into the nature of the disorder, it is the cognitive approach that we feel is the most fully developed and offers the greatest explanatory and predictive power. Cognitive theories of PTSD have...

PTSD within SPAARS

In this section we shall consider how the SPAARS model of emotion accounts for the processing of trauma-related information at the time of the traumatic event and also how that information and the individual's reactions to it are processed subsequent to the traumatic event. The SPAARS approach to PTSD has been spelled out in considerable detail elsewhere (Dalgleish, 1999, 2004a Dalgleish & Power, 2004b), so only a summary of the approach is presented here. At the time of the trauma, we...

Dual representation theory

Brewin et al. (1996) have applied Brewin's (1989) dual representation theory (DRT) to post-traumatic stress reactions in general and to PTSD in particular. This approach endeavours to circumvent some of the difficulties of single-level theories discussed above by proposing two levels in memory at which trauma-related information can be represented. The first level of representation is of the individual's conscious experience of the traumatic event. This forms what Brewin et al. have called...

Ehlers and Clarks cognitive theory

A cognitive-therapy-based model of PTSD has been presented by Ehlers and Clark (2000). The main core of the theory is centred on the proposal that there is a cyclical process that maintains a current and continuing sense of threat, analogous to the cycle that leads to panic in Clark's (1986) model of panic presented earlier in the chapter. The sense of threat is based on the past traumatic event, the nature of the trauma memory, and the negative appraisal of the trauma and its consequences. The...